ZCG Grants Prototype
Back to applications

Grant application

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Evaluation snapshot

Request at a glance

Applicant
OpenPGP Wallet
Requested
$16,500
Funding in payment ledger
$16,500.00May reflect a partial approval; excludes refunds and reimbursements.
Status
Approved
Review context
Forum discussion linked2 committee records linked

FPF source evidence

Milestone and disbursement ledger

Read-only milestone and disbursement fields normalized from the FPF grants ledger.

3 ledger rows

These ledger rows are FPF source evidence. They do not by themselves prove that a progress update was accepted, a payment request was approved, or an on-chain settlement was completed. Named rows can also describe reimbursements, returned funds, or other ledger adjustments.

Infrastructure · Monthly

1

Recorded row amount$9,000.00
Estimate
Not recorded
FPF “Paid Out” date
11/12/2026
FPF “ZEC Disbursed”
9.523 ZEC
FPF “USD Disbursed”
Not recorded
FPF “ZEC/USD” rate
$945.08 / ZEC
FPF ledger status
Open

Infrastructure

2

Recorded row amount$4,500.00
Estimate
25 Jan 2027Dated 1/25/2027
FPF “Paid Out” date
Not recorded
FPF “ZEC Disbursed”
Not recorded
FPF “USD Disbursed”
Not recorded
FPF “ZEC/USD” rate
Not recorded
FPF ledger status
Open

Infrastructure

3

Recorded row amount$3,000.00
Estimate
1 Mar 2027Dated 3/1/2027
FPF “Paid Out” date
Not recorded
FPF “ZEC Disbursed”
Not recorded
FPF “USD Disbursed”
Not recorded
FPF “ZEC/USD” rate
Not recorded
FPF ledger status
Open
AI-grounded decision supportCommittee briefingReview an evidence-grounded briefing or ask a custom question about this application. AI output supports committee review; it does not recommend or make a funding decision.Version 2 · Evidence changed
Evidence changedShared

Committee briefing

7 of 16 evidence records used by this briefing have changed or are no longer available. Regeneration will preserve this version in history.

1. Executive summary and decision snapshot

OpenPGP Wallet requests $16,500 for interoperable shielded-ZEC FROST co-signing specifications, a Rust reference crate, and wallet integration. Khadim, its sole developer, would deliver two acceptance-paid milestones over 11 weeks, with no startup payment. The application is under review. [1][5]

The strongest capability signal is the applicant’s report of three mainnet threshold spends covering all signer pairs. Decision inference: the central question is whether this becomes independently usable interoperability infrastructure, rather than another wallet-specific implementation. [7]

2. Applicant and team track record

Khadim describes himself as a France-based cybersecurity, computer-science and electronics student with penetration-testing and web-development experience. He reports shipping an MIT-licensed Rust/Tauri wallet with 17 releases since September 20, 2026, shielded ZEC support, and Ledger/Trezor integration. These are applicant-reported credentials; no additional team members are listed. [1]

On October 15, he reported three mainnet FROST spends, with the second device independently checking the transaction in two cases, and linked prototype code. This is concrete progress evidence, but not independent verification of the implementation’s security. [7]

Prior ZCG-funded performance or independently accepted milestones: No grounded evidence found. This does not establish that no prior grants exist.

3. Proposal scope, milestones, budget, technical approach, and dependencies

  • Milestone 1 — $9,000, six weeks: desktop FROST 2-of-3 account, distributed key generation, re-randomized PCZT signing with Ironwood, QR-speaking test co-signer, reproducible testnet/mainnet spends, and specification v0.1. [5]
  • Milestone 2 — $7,500, five weeks: published standalone crate, share-backup format with mnemonic and no-recovery-phrase profiles, recovery by sweeping into a fresh FROST account, specification v1.0, and an independent-audit scope. [5]
  • Budget: entirely compensation at $1,500 weekly; hardware and services are budgeted at zero. Public checks include transaction IDs, specifications and crate publication. [10]
  • Architecture: existing FROST components, a shared group descriptor, message envelope and backup format; QR becomes the first transport profile rather than the only possible transport. The applicant says this clarification does not change price or milestones. [7]
  • Boundaries: Android co-signer development and other chains are excluded. General public mainnet release waits for viewing-key standardization and an independent audit; this grant funds audit scoping, not the audit itself. [5]

4. Community discussion, arguments, responses, and resolution

Strongest case for: the applicant identifies incompatible signer messages and backups across wallets, arguing that shared formats could enable portability and reduce dependence on one publisher. Unlike an abstract SDK proposal, this work has a proposed wallet implementation. [5]

Strongest counterweight: cross-wallet compatibility remains prospective. On October 23, Khadim reported Zafe’s agreement to a first cross-implementation signing test and backup comparison, but no completed test result is supplied. This is a useful demand signal, not demonstrated interoperability. [9]

Responses and resolution: Khadim says earlier committee feedback motivated the smaller, delivery-paid proposal. The backup draft now preserves Zkool’s existing payload and allows application-specific extensions. A community concern about implicit key derivation led him to accept an explicit derivation-profile identifier; this resolves design intent, not implementation acceptance. [5][8][9]

No explicit community opposition to this request is documented in the supplied discussion. Remaining technical questions include identifier encoding and test vectors; the backup specification is explicitly still a discussion draft. [8]

5. Relevant precedents and documented outcomes

  • ZeWiF — $121,200, approved: the closest standardization precedent, covering wallet interchange specifications, Rust libraries and recovery tooling. The committee recorded strong technical support and unanimously approved it; five milestones and grant completion are recorded. Adoption or user-recovery outcomes are not documented, so completion should not be treated as impact evidence. Inference: external technical endorsement and implementation partners are useful benchmarks here. [14]
  • FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK — $22,000, declined: directly relevant to reusable FROST infrastructure. Reasons included uncertain application fit and adoption, insufficient involvement from wallet developers, and unresolved secure messaging, backup and recovery. Inference: a narrow format specification addresses a different layer, but still needs demonstrated implementer demand. [15]
  • Threshold custody for shielded ZEC — $47,000, declined: relevant despite its broader organizational-custody scope. The committee cited adoption, maintenance, solo-developer exposure, audit needs and upstream dependencies despite an existing testnet demonstration. Inference: a successful transaction alone did not settle delivery or ecosystem-value concerns. [16]

6. Material risks and execution considerations

  • Setup security: the initial design lets the phone temporarily hold two shares while creating the offline backup; a separate device is an alternative. Inference: the security claim must distinguish steady-state signing from this setup exception. [4]
  • Schedule dependency: the applicant says testnet has moved to NU7 beyond stable library support and plans testing on a pre-release stack. Inference: acceptance timing may depend on upstream compatibility outside his control. [9]
  • Maintenance concentration: specification, implementation, testing, releases and reporting all sit with Khadim. Inference: continuity and post-grant maintenance need explicit arrangements. [1]
  • Value dependency: the funded endpoint is not a generally released, audited consumer product. Inference: committee valuation should separate reusable research/development outputs from future production benefits. [5]

7. Material gaps and questions for the applicant

  • Independent acceptance: who will reproduce the spends and validate signer checks, malformed-message handling, backup restoration and recovery before payment? [5][10]
  • Interoperability threshold: will acceptance require successful Zafe signing and cross-wallet restoration? How will the initial 2-of-2 test establish suitability for the promised 2-of-3 use case? [5][9]
  • Upstream contingency: what happens to scope, deadlines and payment if testnet compatibility or key-generation standardization slips? [7][9]
  • Audit path: who will fund the independent audit, what code will it cover, and how will users be kept outside unaudited production use? [5]
  • Setup threat model: can two-share exposure on one device be eliminated, or clearly bounded and tested? [4]
  • Sustainability: what maintenance commitment, reviewer support and handover documentation accompany the crate and specification? [1][7]

Independent security-review findings, completed cross-wallet tests, and accepted grant milestones: No grounded evidence found.

8. Neutral decision considerations

Committee inference: this is best evaluated as a bounded interoperability-development grant, not a purchase of production-ready threshold custody. Payment on acceptance limits upfront expenditure, while audit and deployment remain separate dependencies. [5]

Possible funding conditions include named independent validators, a reproducible cross-implementation signing-and-recovery test, explicit upstream-delay rules, and a maintenance commitment. These would help distinguish publication of artifacts from demonstrated usability without presuming an approve-or-reject outcome.

9. Numbered source list

  • [1] Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490
  • [5] Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 1–5, part 1 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/1
  • [7] Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 6–10, part 1 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/6
  • [10] Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6151186325
  • [9] Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 11–15 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/11
  • [8] Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 6–10, part 2 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/8
  • [14] Zcash Extensible Wallet Interchange Format (ZeWiF) — comparison summary — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/3
  • [15] FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK: Easy Threshold Custody for Zcash Wallets — comparison summary — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/351
  • [16] Threshold (FROST) custody for shielded ZEC — comparison summary — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/358
  • [4] FROST 2-of-3 between a user's own devices for shielded ZEC (Ironwood) — posts 1–5 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/frost-2-of-3-between-a-users-own-devices-for-shielded-zec-ironwood/58164/1
Evidence coverage16 of 59 records selected

Generation diagnostics show what was available to the briefing process and what was supplied to the model.

Evidence records
16 selected
43 omitted from 59 candidates
Current application share
78%
Of the evidence prompt
Prompt use
62,732 characters
70% of 90,000
Truncated records
0
Selected records shortened to fit the prompt
Primary Forum discussion
Posts
14 packed0 omitted14 available
Discussion chunks
6 packed2 omitted8 available

Omitted discussion remains indexed but was not included in this version's model prompt.

Evidence and citations (16) · 7 changed or unavailable
  1. [1]Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGithub Issue

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: github_issue:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490 Source URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Source title: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: ### Terms and Conditions - [x] I agree to the [Grant Agreement](https://9ba4718c-5c73-47c3-a024-4fc4e5278803.usrfiles.co

  2. [2]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationCanonical Application

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review GitHub labels: name: 📋 Grant Application | status: grant_application | category: intake | name: 👀 Ready For ZCG Review | status: ready_for_zcg_review | category: review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 GitHub issue: 490 GitHub URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 generatedBy: grant_reconciliation_v1 githubLabels: 📋 Grant Application githubLabels: 👀 Ready For ZCG Review sheetRowCount: 0 githubSource

  3. [3]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGoogle Sheet Row

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: google_sheet_row:1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:1164534734:grant-platform:c2d5be0b268f4979bd647fd783a917a070e0fa05a98f81dac82d5d435aa7b553 Source URL: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg/edit?gid=1164534734 Source title: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: Date Submitted

  4. [4]FROST 2-of-3 between a user's own devices for shielded ZEC (Ironwood) — posts 1–5
    Changed since briefingThis applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: FROST 2-of-3 between a user's own devices for shielded ZEC (Ironwood) Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/frost-2-of-3-between-a-users-own-devices-for-shielded-zec-ironwood/58164 Post #1 by Khadim Posted: 2026-10-12 21:19:09.819+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/frost-2-of-3-between-a-users-own-devices-for-shielded-zec-ironwood/58164/1 Post part 1 of 2 Hi Zcash community, I’m Khadim, a solo developer working on OpenPGP Wallet, a non-custodial multi-chain wallet (Rust/Tauri). I’ve written a design for threshold signing of shielded ZEC in the Ironwood poo

  5. [5]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 1–5, part 1
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #1 by Khadim Posted: 2026-10-13 17:02:58.622+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/1 Post part 1 of 2 GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only

  6. [6]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 1–5, part 2
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #4 by aryaethn Posted: 2026-10-13 20:21:34.869+00 Reply to post #3 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/4 Khadim: Your thread and the committee’s feedback on it shaped this application more than anything else Oh, I’m happy knowing that.

  7. [7]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 6–10, part 1
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #6 by Khadim Posted: 2026-10-15 12:43:50.788+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/6 Quick update: the first proof is done, on mainnet. Three FROST 2-of-3 spends of shielded ZEC from the same group, one per pair of signers: ZecBlock Zc

  8. [8]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 6–10, part 2
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #8 by Khadim Posted: 2026-10-19 15:17:20.066+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/8 Small update on the backup side. I wrote a draft of a common member backup format for FROST groups on shielded ZEC: github.com/OpenPGP-Wallet/frost-zec

  9. [9]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 11–15
    Changed since briefingThis applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #11 by benjoshyo Posted: 2026-10-20 07:47:44.742+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/11 Separately, and within what I can actually contribute: once the backup format settles, I’d be glad to document it on the wiki alongside the existing FR

  10. [10]Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGithub Issue Comment

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6151186325 Source URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6151186325 Source title: Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: Confirming the three points: 1. Budget: total $16,50

  11. [11]NoirWallet: FROST Multi-Device Signing Design — posts 1–5, part 1
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: NoirWallet: FROST Multi-Device Signing Design Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/noirwallet-frost-multi-device-signing-design/58170 Post #1 by Noir Wallet Posted: 2026-10-13 14:19:36.341+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/noirwallet-frost-multi-device-signing-design/58170/1 Post part 1 of 3 Link: Noir | Privacy first Wallet 🦓🦓🦓 ⓩ on X: "Ledger has confirmed an unauthorized hardware implant in a device sold via a Southeast Asian reseller. Analysts estimate $80M+ lost. The underlying risk: one device with full spend power is one point of failure. This tr

  12. [12]Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGithub Issue Comment

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6150825235 Source URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6150825235 Source title: Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: Thank you for submitting a grant application to Zcas

  13. [13]Zcash (Both Transparent & Shielded Address) Support for Keystone Hardware Wallet — comparison summary
    Similar ApprovedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: Zcash (Both Transparent & Shielded Address) Support for Keystone Hardware Wallet Applicant: Keystone Team Recorded outcome/status: approved Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionDate: 8/19/24 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionTurnaroundDays: 13 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryStatus: Approved Committee decision (2024-08-19): approved Committee rationale: - The Keystone Team requests $180,900 to integrate Zcash support into their hardware wallet, including both transparent and shielded addresses. The project involves enabling Keys

  14. [14]Zcash Extensible Wallet Interchange Format (ZeWiF) — comparison summary
    Similar ApprovedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: Zcash Extensible Wallet Interchange Format (ZeWiF) Applicant: Blockchain Commons with Zingo Labs Recorded outcome/status: approved Requested amount USD: 121200.00 Application source: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/3 Workflow outcome signal: ✔️ Changes Approved — status changes_approved Workflow outcome signal: ✅ Grant Approved — status approved Workflow outcome signal: ✔️ Grant Complete — status grant_complete Workflow outcome signal: 🎯 Milestone 1 Complete — status milestone_complete — milestone 1 Workflow outcome signal: 🎯 Milestone 2

  15. [15]FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK: Easy Threshold Custody for Zcash Wallets — comparison summary
    Similar DeclinedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK: Easy Threshold Custody for Zcash Wallets Applicant: Mahmud Recorded outcome/status: declined Requested amount USD: 22000.00 Application source: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/351 Workflow outcome signal: ❌ Grant Declined — status declined Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionDate: 7/20/26 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryStatus: Rejected Committee decision (2026-07-20): declined Committee rationale: Applicant proposes a Rust SDK wrapping ZF’s existing FROST stack (frost-core, reddsa

  16. [16]Threshold (FROST) custody for shielded ZEC — comparison summary
    Similar DeclinedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: Threshold (FROST) custody for shielded ZEC Applicant: Aria Naraghi (Individual) Recorded outcome/status: declined Requested amount USD: 47000.00 Application source: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/358 Workflow outcome signal: ❌ Grant Declined — status declined Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionDate: 8/3/26 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryStatus: Rejected Committee decision (2026-08-03): declined Committee rationale: Applicant requests a forward grant to build Ironwood-correct org-grade shielded threshold cust

Version history (1)

Committee briefing

Oct 16, 2026, 12:19 PM UTC

SharedSucceeded

1. Executive summary and decision snapshot

OpenPGP Wallet requests $16,500 for interoperable shielded-ZEC FROST signing and backup specifications, a Rust crate, and a wallet reference implementation. Khadim would deliver it alone. The request is under review, with two acceptance-based payments and no startup funding. [1][5]

The strongest capability evidence is an October 15 applicant report of three mainnet spends covering every signer pair, with independent transaction checking by the second device in two spends. Inference: this supports implementation feasibility, but does not establish cross-wallet interoperability or production security. [7]

The central evaluation question is whether this becomes a genuinely shared standard rather than one wallet’s interface. External adoption, security review, upstream readiness, and solo-developer capacity are the principal delivery/value considerations. [1][4][5][7]

2. Applicant and team track record

Khadim describes a background in cybersecurity studies, penetration testing, and web development. He reports shipping 17 OpenPGP Wallet releases since September 20, 2026, using Rust/Tauri and librustzcash, with shielded-ZEC and hardware-wallet support. These are applicant-reported credentials, not independent assessments. [1]

The mainnet prototype is the most directly relevant work sample; the applicant credits aryaethn’s Ironwood signing work and testnet transaction as implementation references. [7]

Prior ZCG grant performance and independently demonstrated user adoption: No grounded evidence found. The supplied material does not establish whether the applicant has other grant history.

3. Proposal scope, milestones, budget, technical approach, and dependencies

  • Milestone 1 — $9,000, six weeks: desktop FROST 2-of-3 account, test co-signer using QR messaging, reproducible testnet/mainnet Ironwood spends, and specification draft v0.1. [5]
  • Milestone 2 — $7,500, five weeks: standalone crate publication, mnemonic and phrase-free share-backup profiles, recovery by sweeping to a fresh FROST account, reviewed specification v1.0, and an independent-audit scope. [5]
  • Budget: entirely compensation—11 weeks at $1,500/week; hardware and services are budgeted at zero. Payments follow acceptance. Public verification is proposed through transaction IDs, specifications, and crate publication. [5][8]

The design uses existing FROST components, distributed key generation, re-randomized signing over PCZTs, and signer-side transaction checks. The updated scope describes a shared group descriptor, transport-independent envelope, and extensible backup format; QR becomes its first transport profile. The applicant says milestones and budget remain unchanged. [4][7]

A public mainnet release waits for the viewing-key standard and independent audit. An Android co-signer requires a follow-up request; other networks are excluded. The funded audit deliverable is a scope, not the audit itself. [5]

4. Community discussion, arguments, responses, and resolution

Strongest case for: the applicant argues that shared messages and backups could prevent wallet lock-in, reduce duplicated protocol work, and enable signers from different vendors. These are proposed benefits, not demonstrated outcomes. [5]

Strongest challenge raised: aryaethn directed the applicant to the rejected threshold-custody proposal. Khadim responded that its committee feedback shaped this request: an existing wallet, smaller budget, and payment only on delivery. Aryaethn offered conditional collaboration on the ZIP specification, not a firm implementation commitment. [5][6]

Clarifications and partial resolution: the applicant confirmed the budget and public deliverables. The later prototype report supersedes the initial statement that FROST was not implemented. He also reported adopting Hanh’s suggestion of a small common core with application-specific extensions. [8][5][7]

Remaining disagreement: no direct opposing technical review of this request is supplied. The adoption concern remains substantively open: cross-implementation testing is proposed “with whoever is up for it,” rather than backed by a committed wallet partner. [7]

5. Relevant precedents and documented outcomes

  • ZeWiF — $121,200, approved: the closest standards precedent, covering wallet interchange specifications and Rust import/export libraries. Committee support emphasized ecosystem compatibility and favorable technical review. All five milestones are marked complete, but no demonstrated adoption or recovery outcomes are supplied; completion labels do not prove impact. Inference: its relevant lesson is stakeholder-backed standardization, not a price benchmark. [12]
  • FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK — $22,000, declined: committee concerns centered on speculative API fit, weak developer involvement, and unresolved secure messaging, backup, and recovery. Inference: the current application addresses more of those subjects explicitly, but still needs evidence that other wallets will use the result. [13]
  • Threshold custody for shielded ZEC — $47,000, declined: despite a reproduced testnet flow, concerns included adoption, maintenance, solo execution, audit needs, and upstream dependencies. Inference: an operational prototype alone did not settle the committee’s demand and sustainability concerns. [14]

6. Material risks and execution considerations

  • Setup security exception: the design allows the phone to temporarily hold two shares during backup-participant setup, with a spare device offered as an alternative. Inference: the claimed protection against one compromised device needs an explicit setup-phase qualification and reviewed mitigation. [4]
  • Network and standards readiness: the applicant says testnet’s NU7 transition prevented testing with current tools, so the prototype used mainnet. ZIP 2005 keys are reportedly implemented, while ZIP 312 key-generation changes remain pending. Inference: standards alignment in a prototype does not establish release readiness or satisfy the promised testnet demonstration. [7]
  • Schedule concentration: one person owns specification, implementation, tests, releases, and reporting over 11 weeks. Inference: external review and compatibility changes could strain that schedule; acceptance-based payment limits advance-payment exposure but not delivery delay. [1][8]

Independent security-review findings, accepted milestone evidence, and cross-wallet test results: No grounded evidence found.

7. Material gaps and questions for the applicant

  • Which independently maintained wallet will commit to signing and backup-restoration interoperability tests, and will passing those tests be required for acceptance?
  • Who will validate each milestone, and what reproducible evidence will distinguish a functioning threshold protocol from transaction IDs alone?
  • How will testnet delivery be completed if tooling remains incompatible, and what fallback requires committee approval?
  • What threat model and tests cover temporary two-share custody, nonce reuse, malicious coordinators, and backup recovery?
  • Who will fund and perform the independent audit, and what restrictions will prevent premature public release?
  • What maintenance period, compatibility policy, and handover plan are included after the second payment?

These questions target the proposed acceptance model, current testing constraints, security design, release gates, and single-person delivery structure. [1][4][5][7][8]

8. Neutral decision considerations

Inference: the committee can distinguish three kinds of value: a functioning reference implementation, a reusable interoperability standard, and a safe consumer release. The proposed deliverables address the first two; the public release remains dependent on separately completed prerequisites. [5][7]

Possible funding conditions—not an approval recommendation—include named technical reviewers, measurable cross-wallet tests, explicit dependency fallbacks, and documented security/release boundaries. Alternatively, the committee could seek partner commitments and reproducible prototype validation before deciding whether the shared-standard value is sufficiently grounded. These conditions directly address the adoption and execution concerns documented in the FROST precedents. [13][14]

9. Numbered source list

  • [1] Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490
  • [5] Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 1–5, part 1 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/1
  • [7] Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 6–10 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/6
  • [4] FROST 2-of-3 between a user's own devices for shielded ZEC (Ironwood) — posts 1–5 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/frost-2-of-3-between-a-users-own-devices-for-shielded-zec-ironwood/58164/1
  • [8] Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6151186325
  • [6] Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 1–5, part 2 — https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/4
  • [12] Zcash Extensible Wallet Interchange Format (ZeWiF) — comparison summary — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/3
  • [13] FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK: Easy Threshold Custody for Zcash Wallets — comparison summary — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/351
  • [14] Threshold (FROST) custody for shielded ZEC — comparison summary — https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/358
Evidence coverage14 of 55 records selected

Generation diagnostics show what was available to the briefing process and what was supplied to the model.

Evidence records
14 selected
41 omitted from 55 candidates
Current application share
75%
Of the evidence prompt
Prompt use
55,588 characters
62% of 90,000
Truncated records
0
Selected records shortened to fit the prompt
Primary Forum discussion
Posts
8 packed0 omitted8 available
Discussion chunks
4 packed2 omitted6 available

Omitted discussion remains indexed but was not included in this version's model prompt.

Evidence and citations (14) · 7 changed or unavailable
  1. [1]Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGithub Issue

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: github_issue:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490 Source URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Source title: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: ### Terms and Conditions - [x] I agree to the [Grant Agreement](https://9ba4718c-5c73-47c3-a024-4fc4e5278803.usrfiles.co

  2. [2]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationCanonical Application

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review GitHub labels: name: 📋 Grant Application | status: grant_application | category: intake | name: 👀 Ready For ZCG Review | status: ready_for_zcg_review | category: review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 GitHub issue: 490 GitHub URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 generatedBy: grant_reconciliation_v1 githubLabels: 📋 Grant Application githubLabels: 👀 Ready For ZCG Review sheetRowCount: 0 githubSource

  3. [3]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGoogle Sheet Row

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: google_sheet_row:1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:1164534734:grant-platform:c2d5be0b268f4979bd647fd783a917a070e0fa05a98f81dac82d5d435aa7b553 Source URL: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg/edit?gid=1164534734 Source title: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: Date Submitted

  4. [4]FROST 2-of-3 between a user's own devices for shielded ZEC (Ironwood) — posts 1–5
    Changed since briefingThis applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: FROST 2-of-3 between a user's own devices for shielded ZEC (Ironwood) Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/frost-2-of-3-between-a-users-own-devices-for-shielded-zec-ironwood/58164 Post #1 by Khadim Posted: 2026-10-12 21:19:09.819+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/frost-2-of-3-between-a-users-own-devices-for-shielded-zec-ironwood/58164/1 Post part 1 of 2 Hi Zcash community, I’m Khadim, a solo developer working on OpenPGP Wallet, a non-custodial multi-chain wallet (Rust/Tauri). I’ve written a design for threshold signing of shielded ZEC in the Ironwood poo

  5. [5]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 1–5, part 1
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #1 by Khadim Posted: 2026-10-13 17:02:58.622+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/1 Post part 1 of 2 GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only

  6. [6]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 1–5, part 2
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #4 by aryaethn Posted: 2026-10-13 20:21:34.869+00 Reply to post #3 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/4 Khadim: Your thread and the committee’s feedback on it shaped this application more than anything else Oh, I’m happy knowing that.

  7. [7]Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation — posts 6–10
    No current matchThis applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172 Post #6 by Khadim Posted: 2026-10-15 12:43:50.788+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/6 Quick update: the first proof is done, on mainnet. Three FROST 2-of-3 spends of shielded ZEC from the same group, one per pair of signers: ZecBlock Zc

  8. [8]Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGithub Issue Comment

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6151186325 Source URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6151186325 Source title: Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: Confirming the three points: 1. Budget: total $16,50

  9. [9]NoirWallet: FROST Multi-Device Signing Design — posts 1–5, part 1
    This applicationForum Link

    Forum topic: NoirWallet: FROST Multi-Device Signing Design Topic URL: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/noirwallet-frost-multi-device-signing-design/58170 Post #1 by Noir Wallet Posted: 2026-10-13 14:19:36.341+00 Permalink: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/noirwallet-frost-multi-device-signing-design/58170/1 Post part 1 of 3 Link: Noir | Privacy first Wallet 🦓🦓🦓 ⓩ on X: "Ledger has confirmed an unauthorized hardware implant in a device sold via a Southeast Asian reseller. Analysts estimate $80M+ lost. The underlying risk: one device with full spend power is one point of failure. This tr

  10. [10]Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation
    Changed since briefingThis applicationGithub Issue Comment

    Grant application: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Applicant: OpenPGP Wallet Status: under_review Requested amount USD: 16500.00 Source: github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6150825235 Source URL: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6150825235 Source title: Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation Source summary: Thank you for submitting a grant application to Zcas

  11. [11]Zcash (Both Transparent & Shielded Address) Support for Keystone Hardware Wallet — comparison summary
    Similar ApprovedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: Zcash (Both Transparent & Shielded Address) Support for Keystone Hardware Wallet Applicant: Keystone Team Recorded outcome/status: approved Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionDate: 8/19/24 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionTurnaroundDays: 13 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryStatus: Approved Committee decision (2024-08-19): approved Committee rationale: - The Keystone Team requests $180,900 to integrate Zcash support into their hardware wallet, including both transparent and shielded addresses. The project involves enabling Keys

  12. [12]Zcash Extensible Wallet Interchange Format (ZeWiF) — comparison summary
    Similar ApprovedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: Zcash Extensible Wallet Interchange Format (ZeWiF) Applicant: Blockchain Commons with Zingo Labs Recorded outcome/status: approved Requested amount USD: 121200.00 Application source: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/3 Workflow outcome signal: ✔️ Changes Approved — status changes_approved Workflow outcome signal: ✅ Grant Approved — status approved Workflow outcome signal: ✔️ Grant Complete — status grant_complete Workflow outcome signal: 🎯 Milestone 1 Complete — status milestone_complete — milestone 1 Workflow outcome signal: 🎯 Milestone 2

  13. [13]FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK: Easy Threshold Custody for Zcash Wallets — comparison summary
    Similar DeclinedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: FROST Shielded Multi-Sig SDK: Easy Threshold Custody for Zcash Wallets Applicant: Mahmud Recorded outcome/status: declined Requested amount USD: 22000.00 Application source: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/351 Workflow outcome signal: ❌ Grant Declined — status declined Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionDate: 7/20/26 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryStatus: Rejected Committee decision (2026-07-20): declined Committee rationale: Applicant proposes a Rust SDK wrapping ZF’s existing FROST stack (frost-core, reddsa

  14. [14]Threshold (FROST) custody for shielded ZEC — comparison summary
    Similar DeclinedCanonical Application

    Comparable grant: Threshold (FROST) custody for shielded ZEC Applicant: Aria Naraghi (Individual) Recorded outcome/status: declined Requested amount USD: 47000.00 Application source: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/358 Workflow outcome signal: ❌ Grant Declined — status declined Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryDecisionDate: 8/3/26 Documented outcome signal: historicalRegistryStatus: Rejected Committee decision (2026-08-03): declined Committee rationale: Applicant requests a forward grant to build Ironwood-correct org-grade shielded threshold cust

Application-scoped research

Ask about this application

Ask a focused question. Answers use the grant knowledge index and retain numbered links to the evidence supplied to the model.

Your account can read shared analyses but cannot generate a custom answer.

Workflow signals
📋 Grant Application🎯 Milestone 1 Complete🎯 Milestone 2 Complete👀 Ready For ZCG Review✅ Grant Approved
Latest committee record
Approved11/9/2026

Approved

Data quality and provenanceSource matching, linked-record coverage, and reconciliation diagnostics

Source coverage

Operational context for tracing how this canonical record was assembled.
Source stateGitHub + Sheet
GitHub-Sheet match100%
Primary forum2
Supporting forum8
GitHub labels5
Decision notes2

GitHub workflow labels

5 labels captured as structured grant attributes
📋 Grant Application
Category
Intake
Status
Grant Application
Milestone
-
Observed
11/16/2026
Open GitHub issue
🎯 Milestone 1 Complete
Category
Milestone
Status
Milestone Complete
Milestone
1
Observed
11/16/2026
Open GitHub issue
🎯 Milestone 2 Complete
Category
Milestone
Status
Milestone Complete
Milestone
2
Observed
11/16/2026
Open GitHub issue
👀 Ready For ZCG Review
Category
Review
Status
Ready For Zcg Review
Milestone
-
Observed
11/16/2026
Open GitHub issue
✅ Grant Approved
Category
Decision
Status
Approved
Milestone
-
Observed
11/16/2026
Open GitHub issue

Decision history

2 meeting notes linked
Approved11/9/2026

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Approved

Confidence
100%
Match method
Direct Source Url
Minutes
Zcash Community Grants Meeting Minutes 11/9/2026
Remains Open10/23/2026

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Remains open

Confidence
100%
Match method
Direct Source Url
Minutes
Zcash Community Grants Meeting Minutes 10/23/2026

Forum links

2 primary, 8 supporting
Primary forum thread

FROST 2-of-3 between a user's own devices for shielded ZEC (Ironwood)

Hi Zcash community, I’m Khadim, a solo developer working on OpenPGP Wallet, a non-custodial multi-chain wallet (Rust/Tauri). I’ve written a design for threshold signing of shielded ZEC in the Ironwood pool, and I’d like review from people who know FROST and the Orchard protocol well. White pa...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/frost-2-of-3-between-a-users-own-devices-for-shielded-zec-ironwood/58164
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58164 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T08:04:47.048Z | categoryId: 24 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490","github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6151186325"] | postStreamCount: 1

Primary forum thread

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6151186325","google_sheet_row:1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:1164534734:grant-platform:c2d5be0b268f4979bd647fd783a917a070e0fa05a98f81dac82d5d435aa7b553"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/58172/30
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6923284815"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/21
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6743272252"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/26
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6830793744"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/27
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6831354234"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/6
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6192408612"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/7
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6197222348"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

GitHub Issue: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 Requested: $16,500, two milestones, each paid only once accepted, no startup payment Applicant: Khadim, solo developer of OpenPGP Wallet (open source, MIT) Why this, and why now FROST 2-of-3 with a secon...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/8
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58172 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-16T22:37:36.898Z | categoryId: 33 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue_comment:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6270722523"] | postStreamCount: 31

Supporting forum reference

NoirWallet: FROST Multi-Device Signing Design

Link: Noir | Privacy first Wallet 🦓🦓🦓 ⓩ on X: "Ledger has confirmed an unauthorized hardware implant in a device sold via a Southeast Asian reseller. Analysts estimate $80M+ lost. The underlying risk: one device with full spend power is one point of failure. This trigger us to build "NoirWalle...

Confidence
100%
Forum URL
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/noirwallet-frost-multi-device-signing-design/58170/4
Open forum thread

source: forum_mirror | topicId: 58170 | fetchedAt: 2026-11-14T08:07:49.945Z | categoryId: 30 | mirrorKind: forum_topic | coverageCapped: false | discoveredFrom: ["github_issue:ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490"] | postStreamCount: 7

Application source evidence

Primary GitHub, Sheet, and other non-forum source records.
Github Issue

Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

### Terms and Conditions - [x] I agree to the [Grant Agreement](https://9ba4718c-5c73-47c3-a024-4fc4e5278803.usrfiles.com/ugd/9ba471_f81ef4e4b5f040038350270590eb2e42.pdf) terms if funded - [x] I agree to [Provide KYC information](https:/...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | state: open | author: KHADEVS | labels: ["📋 Grant Application","👀 Ready For ZCG Review","✅ Grant Approved","🎯 Milestone 1 Complete","🎯 Milestone 2 Complete"] | number: 490 | closedAt: null | commentCount: 16

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Thank you for submitting a grant application to Zcash Community Grants (ZCG). Please confirm the following before review begins — addressing these upfront will help avoid delays: 1. Confirm your total grant amount equals startup funding ...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6150825235
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: github-actions[bot] | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6150825235 | createdAt: 2026-10-13T17:01:15Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Confirming the three points: 1. Budget: total $16,500 = startup $0 + Milestone 1 $9,000 + Milestone 2 $7,500. All of it is compensation (11 weeks at $1,500 per week); hardware and services are $0. The same figures appear in every section...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6151186325
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6151186325 | createdAt: 2026-10-13T17:21:14Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Update on the forum: three FROST 2-of-3 spends of shielded ZEC on mainnet, one per pair of signers (two of them in two-device mode). https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-refe...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6192408612
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6192408612 | createdAt: 2026-10-15T12:47:08Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Two more updates: A map of the FROST projects for shielded ZEC and how this work connects them, with no change to scope, milestones or budget: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6197222348
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6197222348 | createdAt: 2026-10-15T16:38:51Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Update on the forum: a draft common backup format for FROST members, built on Zkool's zkfrost string. No change to scope, milestones or budget: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6270722523
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6270722523 | createdAt: 2026-10-19T15:19:11Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

**Update** Two notes to keep the application current. Testnet. The application mentions a desktop testnet proof during the review. Testnet moved to NU7 ahead of mainnet, and the current stable librustzcash release doesn't carry the testn...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6360841708
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6360841708 | createdAt: 2026-10-23T08:31:36Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

**Updated** after the October 23 meeting: - The ZIP for the FROST member backup format is now a deliverable, co-owned with @aryaethn (added under Additional Team Members, contributes outside the grant budget). - Milestone 2 goes from $7,...

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6450265608
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6450265608 | createdAt: 2026-10-27T18:25:33Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Update: the ZIP is now open as a pull request, zcash/zips#1432. Details in the forum thread.

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6582575840
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6582575840 | createdAt: 2026-11-02T16:36:39Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/21

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6743272252
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: alexgbo | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6743272252 | createdAt: 2026-11-09T15:01:01Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Update: the Mainnet interop test with Zafe is done, details in the forum thread.

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6751349834
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6751349834 | createdAt: 2026-11-09T21:01:01Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Specification draft v0.1 is up for review: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/26 . Comments are welcome there or as issues on frost-zec.

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6830793744
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6830793744 | createdAt: 2026-11-12T17:22:33Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Milestone 1 is complete. Report and evidence: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/interoperable-frost-co-signing-for-shielded-zec-open-specs-and-a-reference-implementation/58172/27

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6831354234
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6831354234 | createdAt: 2026-11-12T17:45:29Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Thank you for requesting your milestone 1 payout. We just sent you 9.523 ZEC at $945.08 USD/ZEC for a total of $9,000. TXID: 3f42feb1c0719f1b90900456351ac88c4bb2b43f963c18661843fa02eac777f6

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6835516386
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: Duhneekuh | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6835516386 | createdAt: 2026-11-12T20:47:13Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Received, thanks!

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6836816136
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6836816136 | createdAt: 2026-11-12T21:46:49Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Milestone 2 is complete. Report and evidence: https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/58172/30

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6923284815
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: KHADEVS | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6923284815 | createdAt: 2026-11-16T17:04:10Z | issueNumber: 490

Github Issue Comment

Comment on #490: Grant Application - Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Thank you for requesting your milestone 2 payout. We just sent you 4.93 ZEC at $912.75 USD/ZEC for a total of $4500 USD. TXID: 3f4e934f7f873c9dfd53d84813a5155d0bb6af5bb9f1fbcabcc4d9398964ee13

Confidence
100%
Source ID
ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants#490:comment:6933118206
Open source record

repo: zcashcommunitygrants | owner: ZcashCommunityGrants | author: Duhneekuh | number: 490 | issueUrl: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490 | commentId: 6933118206 | createdAt: 2026-11-16T23:57:43Z | issueNumber: 490

Google Sheet Row

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Date Submitted: 10/13/2026 | Proposal Title: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation | Applicant(s): OpenPGP Wallet | Grant Platform Link: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6151186325 | Forum Link:

Confidence
100%
Source ID
1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:1164534734:grant-platform:c2d5be0b268f4979bd647fd783a917a070e0fa05a98f81dac82d5d435aa7b553
Open source record

gid: 1164534734 | sheetId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg | tabName: all_grants_tracking | rowNumber: 730 | identityStrategy: grant_platform_link | businessIdentifier: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6151186325 | rowLocationSourceId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:1164534734:row:730 | businessIdentifierRaw: https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/490#issuecomment-6151186325

Google Sheet Row

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Project: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation | Grantee: OpenPGP Wallet | Category (as determined by ZCG): Infrastructure | Reporting Frequency (as determined by ZCG): Monthly | Milestone: 1 | Amount (USD): $9,000.00

Confidence
100%
Source ID
1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:803214474:row:900
Open source record

gid: 803214474 | sheetId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg | tabName: milestone_details | rowNumber: 900 | identityStrategy: sheet_row_location | rowLocationSourceId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:803214474:row:900

Google Sheet Row

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Project: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation | Grantee: OpenPGP Wallet | Category (as determined by ZCG): Infrastructure | Milestone: 2 | Amount (USD): $4,500.00 | Estimate: 25 Jan 2027

Confidence
100%
Source ID
1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:803214474:row:901
Open source record

gid: 803214474 | sheetId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg | tabName: milestone_details | rowNumber: 901 | identityStrategy: sheet_row_location | rowLocationSourceId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:803214474:row:901

Google Sheet Row

Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation

Project: Interoperable FROST co-signing for shielded ZEC: open specs and a reference implementation | Grantee: OpenPGP Wallet | Category (as determined by ZCG): Infrastructure | Milestone: 3 | Amount (USD): $3,000.00 | Estimate: 1 Mar 2027

Confidence
100%
Source ID
1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:803214474:row:902
Open source record

gid: 803214474 | sheetId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg | tabName: milestone_details | rowNumber: 902 | identityStrategy: sheet_row_location | rowLocationSourceId: 1FQ28rDCyRW0TiNxrm3rgD8ai2KGUsXAjPieQmI1kKKg:803214474:row:902